Company of Heroes: Eastern Front

Eastern Front Mod (Read-Only) => Mapping => Topic started by: SSonne on July 14, 2013, 10:03:25 PM

Title: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: SSonne on July 14, 2013, 10:03:25 PM
Ladies & Gents-
I proudly present:

(http://imageshack.us/a/img607/117/8a6d.jpg)




no need to post any screenshots  ;)
but the Tactical Map:


(http://imageshack.us/a/img46/8927/iwdj.jpg)




-> click HERE (http://www.mediafire.com/download/0m7c6w6mjmvkbcw/4p_pommern.zip) for the latest version  (21.Aug.2013) weather & loading screen incl.
(unzip to: \My Games\Company of Heroes Relaunch\ww2\data )

for upcoming action guaranteed:

(http://imageshack.us/a/img854/9122/e3pf.jpg)




...and as always, please leave a short comment at the end  :D



later then
SSonne


Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: saprize21 on July 15, 2013, 04:23:42 PM
Make a 8 player version :)
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: TheVole on July 15, 2013, 04:57:32 PM
Make a 8 player version :)

(http://www.staffingrobot.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Grumpy-Cat-Says-No.jpg)
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: JuhwannX on July 17, 2013, 05:17:56 AM
I agree with the above statement. I'll actually check this mod out. Maybe it could be added later. MIGHT be better than some of the other EF 2v2 maps, that highly favour axis.
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: Blackbishop on July 17, 2013, 05:44:20 AM
That would be cool :D!
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: Miles Dixon on July 17, 2013, 02:07:54 PM
Looks great as it is easy to defense (on looks). All firepower attention is on the bridge only? Or the river is passable?
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: TheVole on July 17, 2013, 02:50:10 PM
Looks great as it is easy to defense (on looks). All firepower attention is on the bridge only? Or the river is passable?

One would think the center is were the action would be, but it's far to easy to flank the sides by crossing the river. You can't see from the tactical map, but the you can cross the water at most points on the map.
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: saprize21 on July 17, 2013, 03:00:03 PM
Would be sweet if the map had a bridge only option :) So you can only over  the river with the bridge in the middle :)
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: TheVole on July 17, 2013, 03:30:16 PM
Would be sweet if the map had a bridge only option :) So you can only over  the river with the bridge in the middle :)

no, just no...
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: Hendrik 'DarcReaver' S. on July 17, 2013, 03:51:04 PM
Would be sweet if the map had a bridge only option :) So you can only over  the river with the bridge in the middle :)

no, just no...
High ress no pop arty action needs MOAR MAPS!
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: Max 'DonXavi' von B. on July 17, 2013, 04:08:27 PM
Would be sweet if the map had a bridge only option :) So you can only over  the river with the bridge in the middle :)

no, just no...
High ress no pop arty action needs MOAR MAPS!
lol k
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: SSonne on July 17, 2013, 04:44:45 PM
Hey!

thank you all for your comments- this is what I needed right now to keep on mapping  :)

but before you dealing with the thoughts on making it official, I would like to do some finetuning in the starting areas of player 2 + 4  for they were unattended in the 1vs1 Map...
Also I would like to rearrange the sector layout a little bit - for more the chance of cutting the enemy off from ressources...
3rd: I need help with the weather-feature (Maxl?:)  You can choose between rain and nothing but rain, actually ;) 

So are there any bugs, visual terrors, or improvements you would like to see?!?!
please let me know :)


so long
SSonne


@ saprize:
Ill make you a river only version so you can bomb it down all over the place....... and 8 players, of course^^
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: TheVole on July 17, 2013, 05:57:09 PM
(http://i370.photobucket.com/albums/oo148/jackhamershmal/iwdj.jpg~original)

Just a few things I noticed that could be improved upon, the only other thing is the VP's could  maybe be more center oriented.
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: SSonne on July 17, 2013, 06:24:44 PM
@ TheVole:

...and you really know that with most of these changes, this map will act like each (common) others around? ;)

My intention was for the teamplay: one player has to collect the fuel, the other one goes for the mun....
Same with the VPs in the centre- but there is no problem to fix that, if it really hurts....
And you are right when Ive got to lower the MPs and open the encirclements in some areas....

What about the fuel and mun count? acceptable?



greetings
SSonne
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: saprize21 on July 17, 2013, 06:33:40 PM
Hey!

thank you all for your comments- this is what I needed right now to keep on mapping  :)

but before you dealing with the thoughts on making it official, I would like to do some finetuning in the starting areas of player 2 + 4  for they were unattended in the 1vs1 Map...
Also I would like to rearrange the sector layout a little bit - for more the chance of cutting the enemy off from ressources...
3rd: I need help with the weather-feature (Maxl?:)  You can choose between rain and nothing but rain, actually ;) 

So are there any bugs, visual terrors, or improvements you would like to see?!?!
please let me know :)


so long
SSonne


@ saprize:
Ill make you a river only version so you can bomb it down all over the place....... and 8 players, of course^^

Thank you man! :D You have no clue how much u made me happy! :D I love 8 player maps and mega fights :D
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: TheVole on July 17, 2013, 06:47:48 PM
@ TheVole:

...and you really know that with most of these changes, this map will act like each (common) others around? ;)

My intention was for the teamplay: one player has to collect the fuel, the other one goes for the mun....
Same with the VPs in the centre- but there is no problem to fix that, if it really hurts....
And you are right when Ive got to lower the MPs and open the encirclements in some areas....

What about the fuel and mun count? acceptable?



greetings
SSonne

I'm no balancer, but I felt the fuel was to high, Within the first five mins I had about half the map with 50 fuel income and with none of them secured. But on the other side of the spectrum, munitions seemed to be not as abundant as fuel.

Each side get a base of 30 fuel and 25 muni, which is fine. But 20 of that fuel for the axis 20 is right by the bridge and can be taken with ease via the bridge or the river crossing. Where the allies have their 20 fuel right in front of their base. When I was playing as the US I just built two MG squad and sent them to those 2 axis fuel points and locked down while my team mate secured the rest of our side. We won purely because it's very easy for someone to capture those two fuels and defend them, plus we were getting 50 fuel a min...

The Axis fuel points by the river need to be moved back, and maybe a one of those +10 fuels for each side could be changed to +5.
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: SSonne on July 17, 2013, 07:21:22 PM
@TheVole:
Ill follow your suggestions to lower the fuel income and move it a little more to the Axis... but guess what Im doing right now?!





Thank you man! :D You have no clue how much u made me happy! :D I love 8 player maps and mega fights :D


[WIP] :)
8 Bases are already on that map and Ill hope it wont get to warm and toasty  ;)
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: JuhwannX on July 18, 2013, 06:18:01 AM
The map is ridiculously poor to play on. You made a map called " Compstomper Heaven" That should have been related to this map. There are too many houses. The whole "cross the bridge to assault your enemy" is bullshit. The enemy will just do 1 thing. Rush an engineer up to that point. Place Wire. And mines there, and then bam. That's it.

Clean up the tactical map. It's just too cluttered with garbage. Use photoshop to fix that up.
Make all water passable. It's ridiculous that only specific spots of negative cover water are passable. Make all of it passable, and you help mittigate the issue.
      - OR BETTER YET: Just remove the whole bridge mechanic, and just have the player use the freaking roads to get across. Bridge maps/Water Maps suck in
CoH anyway. (I.E. Industrial River, and Blowlands.) I can just imagine this becoming the Pripyat map from CoH 2. Or better known as Scheldt 2.0.

Remove alot the houses for the Axis side. The map is too cluttered with housing. It's really open and forested for the Allies, and yet it's overly cluttered for the Axis. On top of this, due to the water, there are few ways to get around the map with vehicles. So good fucking luck trying to have a tank battle on this overly clustered map. Maps like Sturzdorf, or even Semois, that have towns and all of that have 1 thing that this map doesn't. The open places aren't too open, and the maps aren't too big. It's ridiculous. The Maps so big. Only connecting halves by very easily abusable single location water ways, and a bridge. Also. Why do axis have 2 VP's on their side, while allies don't?

The large amount of houses, make doctrines like Luftwaffa, and Urban WAY too good. And way too abusable. Just make 4 partisans from your opponents own houses and then wait till his army is crossing the bridge. Then BOOM. And honestly, I don't mind matches maybe favouring a doctrine, or not. (Looking at you Freedom Square) But if it's got something going on, it's not that bad. But that's the thing. This map DOESN'T have anything going on with it. There's no definite strategy's. Except arti-spam. And that's going back the the above Scheldt 2.0/ CoH 1 Pripyat/Arti spam map statements.

Also. Make the base sectors freaking bigger. It's so cramped and cluttered. Also fix the MG emplacements. The other player can just go around the other side of the Allies base and then go into it and start wrecking shit. And the Ally player can't do anything against it.

And another thing. Trying to make your map different is cool and all. But don't use that as an excuse for poor map design. Saying "Then it will play like all others." Doesn't excuse you for making your map crappy. The reason why people would want the map to play like others, is because those maps play well. Things like Demyansk, Karachev, Freedom Square ( To an extent), Msstow, are all maps I enjoy, cause they have basic CoH gameplay. Cut-offs. high resources, green cover, good flanking routes, and all of that. Things that make CoH good and different. But this map is like most water maps, and is filled with red cover everywhere. Hell, I'll give Blowlands the fact that there was at least green cover in a FEW places. With this, it's all in the industrial area. MEANING the Wehr, Ostheer, or PE side. So basically all 3 factions can defend their side  so easily, without contest. It's ridiculous. As the only way to get past a defense like that is, guess what? Artillery of some form. Which is just a boring and poor way to design the map. So yes, you can be different. But you can't produce garbage.
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: Hendrik 'DarcReaver' S. on July 18, 2013, 11:05:06 AM
Didn't SSonne say that the water is crossable mostly? Then there's nothing wrong with having a bridge and a river in the middle of the map.

However, I prefer map layouts where the Rivers do not divide the allies/axis but the teams themselves (like on Berlin). 2 players start on each side of the river and start fighting. It's quite cool tbh.
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: JuhwannX on July 18, 2013, 12:39:26 PM
When I was doing some playtests of it earlier, only small parts of the water were crossable. Maybe he's updated it, and my version was old, but I'll try it again this afternoon.
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: SSonne on July 18, 2013, 04:46:26 PM
@JuhwannX:

thx for your statement, also...
Let me get some time to swallow that to find the words you are waiting for ;)
But- dont try one of the first versions for it wasnt changed in river passability: There is the Bridge and way down south for vehicles and 2 other ways in the north for soldiers...  maybe I can ad a few more, but it will still stay a BRIDGE map- if you like/dislike...

The other points you had (the VPs for example) is written in "the rules" of uneven VP-count  and on a BRIDGE map dividing the actors, there is no chance to fix this  (maybe giving the other player +5fuel or something?)  But that wont work,too if annihilate is being played ...

So let me see what others think about this "garbage" and please hold on to you dreams- maybe they´ll come true, somedays :)



greetings
SSonne
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: SSonne on July 21, 2013, 03:06:50 PM
Hy all-


here is the update regarding your suggestions so far:

(http://imageshack.us/a/img713/4332/a2mz.jpg)


1:  added vehicle path
2:  added foot path
3:  swapped Fuel + Mun
4:  added Mun high



additional fixes:

- changed two F10 to F5  (-10 altogether) 
- added barb wire to the bases
- moved and centered VP#3 into the river
- fixed some map-bugs  (tile count)
- added green cover in a few places
- rearranged some mun/fuel points
- added and fixed impassibility
- ...


-> Download see 1st post on top (02. Aug.2013)


please test & comment  :D



l8r
SSonne




PS:
@JuhwannX:
although I wasn't able to take Artillery out of the game  ;)
 your comments are very helpful and always refreshing!
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: TheVole on July 21, 2013, 06:39:48 PM
played it, needs 20 fuel per side, fuel was far to scarce in the match and I was floating 350 muni by mid game. Their is far to much muni and now to little fuel, their should be 20 fuel and 25-30 muni.

Other then that, I think you have made good progress from the first version. But as I said above the resources really need to be fixed.
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: SSonne on July 21, 2013, 09:09:14 PM
Their is far to much muni and now to little fuel, their should be 20 fuel and 25-30 muni.

Hey man,
thank you for testing + feedback  :)

but, let me count : its 25Fuel and 30Mun per side
+ 16Mun extra, reachable by player 1 + 3 almost equal...

(+16 Mun is for the arty-barrage @ JuhwannX)  ;D ;)


should have presented a better tactical map, Im sorry!


Would like to play against real player right now!
Think my comp is a bit to slow to serve a match... but anyways- Im in the MUMBLE right now!


cu there :)

 
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: SSonne on July 23, 2013, 11:19:38 PM
short question @ those who`d downloaded the map:


Should I build an extension to the village almost mirrored to the other side of the river?
And add some cover on the main roads, btw?!

This version isnt etched in stone- and YOUR comments can help me to fix alot....


regards
SSonne
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: JuhwannX on July 24, 2013, 01:52:17 PM
Yes. Add some cover to the main road. And extend the village.
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: SSonne on August 02, 2013, 09:08:07 PM
so I
updated the map  (see 1st post for download- link)

-the village extension could have been bigger, but its all right I think  ;)
-added cover to the roads and some other places
-added specific ai-markers to the players- hoping for faster ai-action in the beginning
-extended the start territories a little
-still no other weather to choose :(

just played a test match and lost  :o

Hoping you enjoy the map by now...


greetings
SSonne
Title: Re: [Finished] Pommern (4)
Post by: SSonne on August 22, 2013, 12:04:16 AM
bumping


for latest version:

-added weather  (rainy afternoon & dawn)
-added some minor visual features


and I think its the most I can do right now, so no further updates in the next future  ;)


once again I updated download link in 1st post ( .zip file, weather & loading screen incl.)


cyas
SSonne